EXCLUSIVE: Liquidator's fall exposes Ella Rouge founders to phoenix allegations

THE founding directors of the Ella Rouge Beauty chain allegedly engineered a phoenix company transaction in 2008 because demands for unpaid payroll tax, workers compensation and other debts threatened to destroy their business.

According to the recently released findings of a liquidator's disciplinary hearing, in early 2008 Mr Ali Hammoud and his wife Ms Manel Issa-Hammoud completed the transfer of assets worth approximately $4 million from their company Ella Rouge Beauty (ERB) to a second company they controlled, Beauty World International (BWI).

The transfer of ERB's assets to a related party via a Business Sale Agreement took place on or around March 28, 2008 but was subsequently backdated to February 28. At the time of the transaction, BWI was the trustee of the Hammoud's Shanel Family Trust. On March 28, ERB changed its name to ERB International Pty Limited.

On April 2, the directors placed ERB International into liquidation, appointing Pino Fiorentino and Bill Hamilton of Hamiltons Chartered Accountants as joint liquidators, with Fiorentino having primary, day-to-day responsibility. The following day, they registered a new company, Ella Rouge Beauty Pty Ltd. This would go on to replace BWI as trustee of the Shanel Family Trust.

In a visualization of their corporate interests provided by Encompass Corporation Ali Hammoud and Manel Issa (Hammoud) were confirmed as  sole directors and shareholders of ERB and BWI at the time the transfer, name change and liquidation were effected.

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) - which has confirmed to Sydney Insolvency News that its investigation into ERB International is ongoing - has alleged that the Business Sale Agreement amounted to a phoenix transaction, which left an insolvent ERB with no valid claim against BWI and debts of approximately $800,000, owed to the Office of State Revenue (OSR), GIO, and specialist workers compensation claims manager Gallagher Basset.

In spite of the allegations, it should be noted that no findings of wrongdoing have been made against Ali and Manel Hammoud. Neither replied to multiple requests for comment.

The allegations have surfaced following a lengthy investigation by ASIC into the conduct of the company's liquidators.

Liquidator denies procuring proxies

SYDNEY liquidator Pino Fiorentino has strenuously denied allegations he procured invalid employee proxies and voted them in support of a resolution to approve his fees. 

"I never procured anything,” the registered and official liquidator told Sydney Insolvency News (SiN) during a break in a hearing before the Federal Court last week.

“I made a mistake. I didn’t check the proxies. There’s no way I told the director, ‘fill out the proxies and sign them yourself’,” he said.

Fiorentino's comments came as the Federal Court heard his application for a judicial review of a hearing held before the Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board (CALDB) last February.

In late January and early February this year CALDB rejected several applications by Fiorentino for an adjournment of a hearing brought before CALDB by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), which is seeking cancellation of Fiorentino’s liquidator’s registration.

The last adjournment application, made on February 2, proceeded without Fiorentino being present for the bulk of the hearing. Nor was he represented by legal counsel.

CALDB went on to refuse the adjournment application and on February 4 heard the ASIC application. Fiorentino is challenging CALDB’s refusal to grant the adjournment and the subsequent hearing of the ASIC application. At time of writing CALDB had not made its determinations and reasons public.

In an outline of Fiorentino’s Federal Court submissions obtained by SiN, the impact of the proceedings currently  before CALDB is described as “grave” because “ …. the orders sought by ASIC amount to no less than causing the permanent end to the career of the Applicant”. 

The ASIC application was formally brought before CALDB in 2013 following an investigation by the regulator into ERB International, which had owned the Ella Rouge Beauty salon chain.

Insolvency veteran slapped with suspension

Bill Hamilton
Photo: WJ Hamilton & Associates

BILL Hamilton, one of Australia's longest serving insolvency practitioners, has had his liquidator's registration suspended for six months following a hearing before the Companies Auditors & Liquidators Disciplinary Board (CALDB).

Details of the suspension and future compliance requirements were published in the Commonwealth Gazette yesterday, more than five months after the CALDB hearing, which took place on November 5, 2013. 

Hamilton, who began practising in 1960, last week advised the Australian Restructuring Insolvency & Turnaround Association (ARITA) that the decision was imminent. 

In a statement ARITA said: "In accordance with clause 7.1(b)(i) of the ARITA Constitution, Mr Hamilton's ARITA membership has been automatically suspended for six months effective from 2 June 2014 following a decision by the Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board (CALDB)".

CALDB found that Hamilton did not adequately and properly perform his duties as a joint liquidator by entering into a deed of settlement and release with the directors of ERB and a director-related company to accept an amount which had not been properly assessed.